By Brendan Loy
ESPN's newest basketball analyst, Bobby Knight, made his SportsCenter debut tonight. His analysis of the Villanova-Syracuse game was underwhelming -- his expert opinion was that the momentum 'Nova built by finishing the first half on an 8-0 run was, er, important -- but he'll probably get better at saying slightly more insightful things as he gets more used to his new role. What was more concerning was his answer when asked his opinion about the respective at-large merits of Villanova and South Alabama, and, more generally, how he feels about the always-vexing question of comparing major-conference teams from the middle ranks of the standings with top-tier teams from mid- and low-major conferences.
Knight's answer was -- and this isn't an exact quote, but it's a close paraphrase -- that he pretty much always favors major-conference teams, whenever they're anywhere near the bubble, because they play tougher schedules.
Needless to say, he didn't address the fact that those tougher schedules are already taken into account by the fact that we're comparing mid-major teams with records like 26-6 to major-conference teams with records like 20-11. As far as Knight is concerned, schedule strength is apparently pretty much the only thing that should matter. The fact that the non-major teams under consideration at least partially made up for their weaker schedules by winning more games apparently doesn't even figure into the equation.
So basically, if it were up to Bobby Knight, teams like St. Mary's, Illinois State, VCU, South Alabama, and (if they lose the MAC tourney) Kent State would all be out, replaced by mediocre BCS-conference squads like Syracuse, Maryland, Virginia Tech, Florida and Ole Miss. Oh, that'd be thrilling. An NCAA Tournament utterly devoid of potential Cinderellas. Awesome.
Luckily, Bobby Knight isn't on the selection committee. But on top of the possible Great Billy Packer Eruption of 2008 over on CBS, I guess we can look forward to Knight's grumpy commentary on ESPN, wondering how a team like St. Mary's could possibly get in over a team like Ohio State. I hope ESPN lets Knight and Dick Vitale appear on-air together at some point during the post-selection show. It would be fun, in the seemingly inevitable event of a major-vs.-mid-major selection controversy, to watch the always-energetic champion of the little guy go toe-to-toe with the chair-throwing defender of the BCS conferences.
My other sites